Why the argument that immigration is the only real reason behind hovering house costs is flawed

By
Millicent Wong
-
0
553
Top Stories newsletter logo

  1. Real estate

The argument became a serious challenge in 2020 when immigration rates dropped significantly due to pandemic restrictions, but house prices continued to escalate

Author of the article:

Murtaza Haider and Stephen Moranis, Special for Financial Post More buyers looking for fewer homes to buy and rent is at the heart of home price inflation.More buyers looking for fewer homes to buy and rent is at the heart of home price inflation. Photo by Cole Burston / Bloomberg Files

Soaring house prices in Canada have fueled an exciting and highly relevant debate about their determinants, such as whether the demand for housing is growing too fast as some believe, or whether supply is lagging demand, causing more buyers for fewer units compete to buy and rent.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

A recent comment suggests that the demand for new housing is a direct result of net population growth, which is mainly driven by immigration. According to Statistics Canada, international migration has accounted for more than three quarters of total population growth since 2016, reaching 85.7 percent in 2019.

If immigration is the reason for the population growth driving demand for housing, it can be argued that Canada should perhaps reconsider the number of immigrants it accepts each year in order to ease pressure on housing and infrastructure.

Canada’s economy has grown almost in step with population growth over the years. World Bank data shows that the country’s gross domestic product (GDP) per capita has more than doubled since 1990. Canada’s GDP per capita used to be similar to the United States, but the gap has widened since 2012.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Some argue that growing the economy by increasing the population is not the right approach. They say Canada should focus on increasing economic productivity by exploring ways to increase its GDP per capita, which may require lower population growth to sustain economic growth. Some believe that this would make housing prices more affordable because there would be less demand.

But the argument that immigration is the main driver of house prices in Canada became a serious challenge in 2020 when immigration rates dropped significantly due to pandemic restrictions. Canada’s population rose 0.4 percent in 2020, a quarter of the increase seen a year earlier, according to Statistics Canada.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

To put these numbers in perspective, consider that 2020 “had the lowest annual growth since 1945 (in numbers) and 1916 (in%), both times Canada was at war,” Statistics Canada said. In addition, immigration played a much smaller role in population growth, so that the “population growth due to international migration in 2020 was over 80 percent lower than in 2019”.

Those who argue that immigrants and foreign investors are the main determinants of house price inflation could find it difficult to explain what role, if any, new immigrants played in the record escalation in house prices during the pandemic. Most of the borders have been closed, immigration numbers have declined, and international capital flows have been stifled due to economic uncertainty.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Underneath the rhetoric for and against population growth hides the unevenness of the demographic landscape across Canada. As the country’s population grew, hundreds of small and medium-sized towns declined. Even Montreal’s population fell from 1.77 million in 1971 (the year with the highest population in the city) to 1.7 million in 2016.

Maxwell Hartt, professor of geography and planning at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, examined the uneven population growth in cities and towns as the population declined in his recent book Quietly Shrinking Cities: Canadian Urban Population Loss in an Age of Growth. The book presents a meticulous study of why people are leaving a city or have fewer children, leading to a population decline.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Hart said immigration is critical to stabilizing Canada’s population growth. Without them, the population would have shrunk because Canadians haven’t had enough children since 1972 to replace themselves.

The differences and similarities between shrinking cities and others are fascinating. Hart observed, for example, that both shrinking and growing cities were similar in terms of Aboriginal populations and the percentage of adults with post-secondary education.

What set shrinking cities apart was that their populations were older and had fewer immigrants and visible minorities. The proportion of immigrants in growing cities was 83 percent higher than in shrinking cities, while the proportion of visible minorities in growing cities was more than double that in shrinking cities.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

  1. A terrace of houses on a hill in Birstall, UK

    Providing the housing you need is easier said than done – just ask our friends in the UK

  2. Rental housing accounts for more than half of Halifax's new home construction.

    The secret behind Halifax’s ability to build purpose-built rental housing at record speed

  3. A house under construction in Calgary.

    Establishing land use planning is key to accelerating housing construction and improving affordability

Shrinking cities experience no demand-side pressure on housing. In relation to income, housing is far cheaper there than in cities with growing populations. But shrinking cities continue to shrink. Relative affordability and the lack of population pressures make a place not desirable enough for residents to stay and keep the population stable.

Demand-side pressure on housing and infrastructure is only one aspect in determining an appropriate level of immigration. Another consideration is how much labor it will take to sustain economic growth and replace a rapidly aging workforce.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

The housing demand discussion is relevant, but it shouldn’t cover up the fact that Canada has a supply problem. Fewer homes have been built in recent years than in the early 1970s, when the population was much smaller.

More buyers looking for fewer homes to buy and rent is at the heart of home price inflation. Removing supply-side alternatives from the solution mix will only make matters worse.

Murtaza Haider is Professor of Real Estate Management at Ryerson University. Stephen Moranis is a real estate industry veteran. They can be reached on the Haider-Moranis Bulletin website www.hmbulletin.com.

This ad hasn’t loaded yet, but your article continues below.

In-depth coverage of The Logic’s innovation economy, made available to you in collaboration with the Financial Post.

    By clicking the registration button, you agree to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link at the bottom of our emails. Postmedia Network Inc. | 365 Bloor Street East, Toronto, Ontario, M4W 3L4 | 416-383-2300

    Remarks

    Postmedia advocates a lively but civil discussion forum and encourages all readers to share their thoughts on our articles. Comments can take up to an hour to be moderated before they appear on the site. We ask that you keep your comments relevant and respectful. We turned email notifications on – you will now receive an email when you’ve received a reply to your comment, there’s an update on a comment thread you’re following, or when a user follows a comment. Check out our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to customize your email settings.